Neighborhood Guide

Island Lake, IL

Island Lake, IL is a village of about 8,000 people built around an 85-acre man-made lake on the Lake and McHenry county line, with home prices well under the Lake County norm and no train station of its own.

Living in Island Lake, IL means a village built around its own lake, a median sale price of about $330,000 this summer and property tax near 2.2 to 2.4% of value. The trade-offs are a drive to the nearest Metra station and a small downtown along Route 176. Here is how it breaks down, pocket by pocket.

Written by Eshu Chikoti · 847-691-4282 ·

Illustration of a lake with a small island, shoreline homes and moored boats from a village beach, representing Island Lake in Island Lake, Illinois
AI illustration, not a photo of Island Lake.
Commute to Chicago (Metra)
No station; Cary express ≈ 47 min
Median Sale Price
≈ $330K (Jun–Aug 2026)
Public Schools
Mostly Wauconda CUSD 118
Highway Access
IL-176, with US-12 and IL-59 nearby
Property Tax
≈ 2.2% to 2.4% effective
Walk Score
Car-dependent (≈ 0.2 restaurants in a 5-min walk)
Full In-Depth Guide
Background

How Island Lake, IL Got Here: A Short History

The name promises a lake with an island, and for most of history there was neither. According to the history section of the village's 2023 Comprehensive Plan, the land was rolling farmland, a gravel pit and Mutton Creek. In 1929 a group of area residents, including Ray Paddock, Homer Cook and Dennis Putnam, bought the land and decided to dam Mutton Creek and build a lake development patterned after their own town of Wauconda.

A 2025 lake-restoration brief the village posted describes the result as a former gravel pit dammed in the early 1930s into an 84.8-acre lake. Both accounts agree on the part that matters for a buyer today: the lake is man-made, fed by the Mutton Creek and Cotton Creek watershed, and managed by the village rather than by a homeowners association.

The first homes were summer cottages. The Island Lake Property Owners Association formed in 1938. After World War II, the housing shortage sent Chicago-area buyers looking for rural property, the cottages were gradually converted to year-round homes, and new construction filled in the remaining lots. The village incorporated on June 25, 1952.

Two later events shaped the village you see now. On Palm Sunday, April 11, 1965, a tornado hit Island Lake, killed a child and lifted some homes into the lake; the plan notes that a year later only a few scars remained. Then in 1980 the village annexed about 800 acres known as Fox River Shores, growing to roughly 1,300 acres. About 250 acres of that annexation became the Cotton Creek Marsh conservation area. Most of the housing built in the 1980s and 1990s sits on land added in that era.

The Basics

Island Lake at a Glance

Island Lake covers 3.56 square miles on the line between Lake County and McHenry County, about 40 miles northwest of the Loop. The Lake County side is in Wauconda Township and the McHenry County side is in Nunda Township, according to Wikipedia's summary of Census data. The village's own plan describes its limits as running west to the Fox River, north toward Dowell and Darrell Roads, east along Darrell Road and south toward Roberts and Porten Roads. Neighbors are Wauconda to the east, Lakemoor and Volo to the north, Port Barrington to the west and the Barrington area to the south.

The county line is the first thing to understand, because it runs through the village and changes the tax bill, the assessor, sometimes the school district and the county you call for permits and beach advisories. Two houses a few blocks apart can be in different counties. Every Island Lake listing should say which county the parcel is in. If it doesn't, ask before you run the numbers.

The 2020-2024 Census ACS puts the population at 8,014 in 3,073 housing units, and 82.7% of occupied homes are owner-occupied. The 2020 Census count was 8,051, and the village's plan notes the population nearly doubled between 1990 and 2000 and has barely moved since.

Route 176 is the spine. It runs east to west through the middle of the village and carries the downtown businesses, Village Hall on Greenleaf Avenue just off it, and most of the traffic. Locals describe where they live by which side of 176 they are on and how close they are to the water.

Every Metra commute starts with a drive to Cary or Fox River Grove, Route 176 backs up at rush hour, and the county line makes taxes and school assignment something to check house by house. On the lake itself, factor in the phosphorus problem the village is treating.

Island Lake limits outlined in navy (U.S. Census Bureau); Metra stations in gold (Metra). Drag to move, + and − to zoom.
Where to Look

Island Lake Neighborhoods, Pocket by Pocket

Island Lake has no official neighborhoods, but it splits into three kinds of places. The first is the original lake settlement: the winding streets around the water, where the oldest homes are, many of them former cottages. The second is the large block of 1980s and 1990s subdivisions, much of it on the land annexed in 1980, with more regular streets, larger lots and newer houses. The third is the small amount of townhome and attached housing, mostly off Route 176.

The Census ACS shows how lopsided that is. Of 3,073 homes, 1,655 (54%) were built between 1980 and 1999, and the median year built is 1990. Only 469 homes, about 15%, date to before 1950, and those are concentrated near the lake. Newer construction is rare: 91 homes since 2010.

Below are the names you will see on listings. Boundaries are informal, and several of these come from one source, so treat them as a starting point. If you want to know which pocket a specific address falls in, which county it is in and what it would cost to carry, that is a conversation I am happy to have here.

The pattern that matters most in Island Lake is water. The village's plan says it plainly: waterfront property remains at a premium. A lakefront or channel lot and an inland house of the same size can be priced very differently, and the lake lot comes with its own checklist, covered further down.

Illustration of a winding lakeside street with a small original cottage next to a newer rebuilt home, typical of Island Lake, Illinois
Illustrative image, not a photo of this exact spot.
Neighborhoods placed at the center of their homes in MLS listing records; Island Lake limits outlined in navy (U.S. Census Bureau). Drag to move, + and − to zoom.

Island Lake Estates. The original lake-area settlement. Subdiview describes a mix of former cottages and larger rebuilt homes near the water, with village beach and lake access.

Island Lake Highlands. A lake-oriented area of single-family homes near the water, per Subdiview. Ask which beach and which boat access a specific house uses.

Fox River Shores. The 1980 annexation of about 800 acres. Subdiview lists homes built 1984 to 1998, single-family and townhouses, in the southern part of the village.

Walnut Glen. A Redfin-named neighborhood on the Lake County side. The village is working through a sale of 49 vacant acres here to a builder (see the development section).

Boulevard Park and Champion Farms. Neighborhood names Redfin and Walk Score use for parts of the village. Confirm the subdivision name on the listing itself.

Southport Village. Listed by Homes by Marco as one of the village's starter-home subdivisions; homes on Southport Drive date to the early 1990s.

Westridge. Named by the same source as the village's higher-priced subdivision.

Waters Edge. Attached homes off Route 176 from around 2000, per Subdiview.

Homes

What Island Lake Homes Look Like, by Era

The oldest layer is the lake cottage. Around the water you will find small homes that started as summer places in the 1930s and 1940s, many of them expanded, winterized and re-sided over the decades. Some have been torn down and replaced. The village wants the originals kept: its plan encourages owners to renovate and restore them, and it added an Island Lake Overlay District to the zoning code to give those homes more flexibility.

The biggest layer is the 1980s and 1990s subdivision house: raised ranches, split-levels, two-story colonials and some townhomes, usually on regular lots with attached garages. That era accounts for more than half of the village. The Census ACS counts 2,346 detached single-family homes (76%) and 623 attached single-family homes (20%), with very few apartments.

The ACS puts the median value of owner-occupied homes at $262,500 and median gross rent at $1,874. Recent public sales show the spread. On Redfin's Island Lake page, closings from late August to mid-September 2026 ran from $237,500 for a two-bedroom of about 1,083 square feet to $405,000 for a 2,350-square-foot three-bedroom.

Buying a lake cottage is different from buying a 1990s colonial, and the inspection should reflect that. On the older homes I'd look hard at the foundation and crawl space, the electrical panel, how the addition was tied in and whether it was permitted. On any lot near the water, ask about the shoreline and about water in the lower level. My home inspection checklist is a good place to start.

Illustration of a lake cottage and a 1990s two-story home, typical of Island Lake, Illinois
Illustrative image, not a photo of this exact spot.
The Real Estate Market

The Island Lake Housing Market in 2026

Island Lake prices went up this year, not down. In the three months ending August 2026, Redfin reported a median sale price of $329,682, up 9.9% from the same period a year earlier. The median price per square foot was $217, up 8.7%. Homes sold at 100.4% of list price on average, and Redfin gives the village a Compete Score of 80 out of 100, which it calls very competitive, with about two offers per home.

Zillow's home value index tells the same story more gently. It put the typical Island Lake home at $309,230 in August 2026, up 6.1% from $291,490 a year earlier and up about 11% from $278,394 in August 2024. Redfin's number is the middle of what actually sold in a three-month window; Zillow's estimates every home, sold or not. When both rise, the rise is real.

The older version of this page said prices were falling. That was based on a list-price snapshot from mid-2025. The sales data for 2026 points the other way, and I'd rather correct it than leave it.

Two numbers moved against sellers. Homes took a median of 44 days to sell, up from 38 a year earlier, and sale-to-list slipped slightly. More homes are selling (50 in August 2026 against 34 a year earlier, per Redfin), and buyers have a little more time to decide. A well-priced house still goes quickly; one priced off last year's peak sits. For the broader picture, see my Lake County market report for Q3 2026.

Typical home value
 
Source: Zillow Home Value Index, all homes, smoothed and seasonally adjusted.
The Real Estate Market

Island Lake Property Taxes and the Real Cost of Owning

Island Lake's property tax rate depends on which county you are in. As of April 2026, Ownwell's Lake County data puts the median effective rate for the Lake County side at 2.22%, with a median bill of $5,218. Its McHenry County data puts the McHenry side at 2.38%, with a median bill of $5,788. Both are below their county medians (2.61% in Lake County and 2.42% in McHenry County, per the same pages).

Here is what that looks like on a purchase. At 2.2% to 2.4%, a house bought at this summer's $329,682 median would eventually carry roughly $7,300 to $7,900 a year in tax, about $600 to $660 a month on top of the mortgage. The median bills above are lower because they are based on older assessments. Assessments trail the market, and the gap usually closes in the years after a sale. The expectation I most often have to reset is a buyer budgeting off the seller's current bill.

The two counties run separate assessors, separate appeal calendars and separate tax bills. Each combination of township, school district, library district and sewer district is its own tax code, so confirm the actual code for the parcel. Lake County's tax-rate tables are hard to pull automatically, so I check those by hand for a specific address.

Two smaller costs are new or worth knowing. The village adopted a municipal grocery tax in 2025 to replace the state grocery tax that ended on January 1, 2026. And water is billed by the village quarterly: a $40 service fee plus $9.00 per thousand gallons, per the village's new-resident sheet, with sewer billed separately by the reclamation district.

If you already own and think your assessment is high, my Lake County property tax appeal guide walks through the process on the Lake County side. This is general information, not tax advice. Your actual bill depends on your parcel, your exemptions and the assessor.

Schools

Island Lake Schools: District 118 and the McHenry-Side Exception

Most of Island Lake is served by Wauconda Community Unit School District 118, a single prekindergarten through 12th grade district. According to the district, it serves nearly 4,500 students from Wauconda, Island Lake, Lake Barrington, Lakemoor, Port Barrington and Volo, plus unincorporated areas in four townships. It runs three elementary schools (Cotton Creek, Robert Crown and Wauconda Grade School), two middle schools (Matthews and Wauconda Middle School) and Wauconda High School.

Two of those schools are in Island Lake itself. Cotton Creek School is at 545 Newport Court, and Matthews Middle School, grades 6 through 8, is at 3500 Darrell Road. High school is Wauconda High School in Wauconda.

The exception is the county line. The village's 2023 plan says Island Lake is served mainly by District 118 "along with School Districts 15 and 156," the McHenry-area elementary and high school districts, and says the village would like a single district someday. Don't assume from the town name. Check the exact address with the district before you write an offer, and ask me for the boundary if you want it done for a specific house.

Illustration of a brick middle school front entrance, representing Matthews Middle School in Island Lake, Illinois
AI illustration, not a photo of Matthews Middle School.

Cotton Creek School. 545 Newport Court, Island Lake. Elementary, District 118.

Matthews Middle School. 3500 Darrell Road, Island Lake. Grades 6 to 8, District 118.

Wauconda High School. Wauconda. District 118.

Robert Crown School, Wauconda Grade School and Wauconda Middle School. The other District 118 schools, all in Wauconda.

Districts 15 and 156. The McHenry-area elementary and high school districts that cover some Island Lake addresses, per the village plan.

Commute & Access

Commuting from Island Lake: The Nearest Metra Stations

Island Lake has no Metra station, so every train commute starts with a drive. For most of the village the closest stations are on the Union Pacific Northwest line into Ogilvie Transportation Center: Cary and Fox River Grove, both to the south across the Fox River.

According to Metra's schedule for Cary, 27 inbound trains stop there on a weekday. The rush-hour expresses are the ones to plan around. The 6:15, 6:45, 7:15 and 7:45 a.m. trains from Cary reach Ogilvie in about 47 minutes. Most other trains take about 67 to 68 minutes. Fox River Grove, one stop closer to the city, has a similar weekday schedule.

The older version of this page pointed to Round Lake and Long Lake on the Milwaukee District North line. Those work for the north edge of the village, but for most addresses Cary is the shorter drive and has the faster trains. For Island Lake buyers the real test is drive plus parking plus train. I'd time it on a weekday morning before you buy, because the Route 176 and Fox River crossings are where the morning backs up.

The Census ACS puts the mean travel time to work at 31.9 minutes, which tells you most residents work in the suburbs rather than downtown.

Illustration of a commuter train arriving at a station platform, representing the Cary Metra station in Island Lake, Illinois
AI illustration, not a photo of the Cary Metra station.
Commute & Access

Driving from Island Lake: Route 176 and the Bridges

Route 176 runs straight through Island Lake and is the road almost everyone uses. East, it reaches US-12 (Rand Road) near Wauconda and the roads toward Mundelein and the Tri-State. West, it crosses the Fox River toward Crystal Lake. Roberts Road runs southeast to IL-59 at Tower Lakes, the usual route toward Barrington and the northwest suburbs. There is no interstate nearby, so plan on surface roads for the first stretch of any trip.

Traffic is the village's own top complaint. Its 2023 plan explains why: the Fox River is bridged only at Route 176, Rawson Bridge Road and the Charles J. Miller bridge to the north, so drivers from growing towns to the west and northwest funnel through Island Lake on 176 to reach US-12 and IL-59. The plan supports eventually widening Route 176 to five lanes, which sits in Lake County's long-range plans with no funding or date, and wants Dowell and Case Roads developed as a second east-west route. Burnett Road, which some drivers use to skip 176, is meant to stay residential.

Island Lake is also one of the few towns that is openly golf-cart friendly. Carts and other off-highway vehicles need a $20 village sticker, and the plan calls the village "golf cart/UTV friendly." Around the lake, a golf cart is a real way to get to a beach or a friend's dock.

Commute & Access

Is Island Lake Walkable?

For errands, no. Walk Score counts about 20 restaurants, bars and coffee shops in the village and says a resident can walk to an average of 0.2 of them in five minutes. The grocery store, gas stations and banks are on Route 176, and most homes are a drive from them.

For the lake, it depends on the street. Homes near the water can walk to one of the village beaches, and the streets around the lake are quiet enough for an evening walk or a bike ride. The village plan calls for more bike and cart paths and asks new developments to include sidewalks, but many older streets near the lake have none.

For longer outings, the open land around the village is the draw. Moraine Hills State Park is just to the northwest, and the McHenry County Conservation District's land along the Fox River and the Cotton Creek Marsh sits on the south and west edges.

Shopping

Downtown Island Lake and Shopping on Route 176

Island Lake's downtown is the stretch of Route 176 around the lake. The village's own plan describes it as utilitarian, with a mix of building styles, parking in front of most stores and many driveways onto the highway. It covers the basics: the grocery store, gas, banks, a Dunkin' and local service businesses.

The plan commits the village to improving that corridor rather than letting it fade, including a corridor study, support for a local business association and streetscape work when funding allows. It also points to vacant parcels along 176 as the places it wants new commercial and office uses.

For bigger shopping, most residents drive east to Wauconda and Lake Zurich or west to Crystal Lake. Randall Road in Crystal Lake and Algonquin has the big-box stores, and Wauconda's Route 176 corridor is the closest place for most chain errands. My guide to Wauconda covers that side.

Illustration of a commercial strip along a state route, representing Route 176 in Island Lake in Island Lake, Illinois
AI illustration, not a photo of Route 176 in Island Lake.
Everyday Life

Groceries and Everyday Errands in Island Lake

The biggest change in town this year was the grocery store coming back. Island Foods operated on Route 176 from 1972 until it closed about two and a half years before the reopening, and the village went that whole time without a grocery store. According to the Northwest Herald, the Lomeli family, who run a smaller supermarket in Round Lake, reopened the building as Lomeli's Fresh Market on December 23, 2025, after extensive plumbing, ventilation and utility work.

The store is about 23,000 square feet, with a full-service butcher counter, produce, a bakery, a hot deli with its own kitchen and general groceries. It sits at 233 E. State Road, which is Route 176, right on the county line.

For a bigger weekly shop, the Jewel-Osco on Liberty Street in Wauconda is the closest chain store, and Crystal Lake and Lake Zurich have the rest. Banks and gas are on Route 176 in the village.

Dining & Everyday Life

Where Island Lake Eats

Island Lake is not a restaurant destination, and it doesn't pretend to be. Walk Score counts about 20 restaurants, bars and coffee shops inside the village, mostly casual places along Route 176, plus the hot deli counter at Lomeli's. The village's events calendar is a good guide to the local gathering spots, including the village Dunkin' that hosts the police department's "Cop on the Rooftop" fundraiser.

The village's plan points to a second dining option most guides skip: the Fox River around Burton's Bridge, just north and west of the village, where boating businesses and riverside restaurants cater to people out on the water. For a wider choice, downtown Wauconda and Crystal Lake are each a short drive, and my Wauconda guide covers the places on Bangs Lake.

The Lomeli's building also has room to grow. When the store reopened, the owners said the former bank branch and hardware store on the same site were available for restaurant or retail tenants.

Parks & Recreation

The Lake, the Beaches and Parks in Island Lake

The lake is the reason to look here. It covers about 85 acres, and it is managed by the village, not an association. The village lists four swim beaches: Brier Beach, South Shore Beach, Dorothy Beach and Veterans Park Beach. Beach advisories come from the Lake County and McHenry County health departments, and the village posts open and closed notices on its parks and beaches page.

Boats need a village sticker. According to the village's lake rules booklet, a resident sticker is $20 for the first boat and $15 for each additional boat, and a nonresident sticker is $40. The booklet sets horsepower limits, with fines of $200 to $750 for violations, and lists the fish in the lake, including largemouth bass, walleye, northern pike, muskellunge, crappie, bluegill and channel catfish. If a house comes with a pier, ask what motor the previous owner ran.

There is a water-quality issue to know about, and I'd rather you hear it here. A 2025 restoration brief posted by the village reports that testing from May through September 2021 found average total phosphorus of 0.158 mg/L, more than three times the Illinois EPA's 0.050 mg/L impairment threshold, which feeds algal blooms. The village runs a seasonal lake treatment program and posts every treatment notice on its lake news page. It is being managed, and it is also the kind of thing to watch before you pay a lakefront premium.

On land, the ball fields at 3720 Greenleaf Avenue next to Village Hall were rebuilt this year. The Northwest Herald reported in August 2026 that a youth baseball league renovated the fields in exchange for using them, a local businessman donated a scoreboard, and the village is planning pickleball courts. The same story notes the village no longer has a parks and recreation department. Outside the village, Moraine Hills State Park and the 247.5-acre Cotton Creek Marsh, which the village plan says hosts nesting sandhill cranes, are the big open spaces.

Illustration of a swim beach on a lake in summer, representing a village swim beach on Island Lake in Island Lake, Illinois
AI illustration, not a photo of a village swim beach on Island Lake.
Community Resources

Library Service in Island Lake

Most of Island Lake is served by the Wauconda Area Public Library, a library district whose main building is on North Main Street in Wauconda. Because it is a district, its service area reaches beyond Wauconda into Island Lake and neighboring villages, and cardholders can borrow from other libraries through its consortium.

As with schools, the county line matters. Parts of the McHenry County side may fall in a different library district, so check the district on the tax bill for a specific parcel. The library district is one of the lines on that bill, so it is easy to confirm before you buy.

Practical Logistics

Utilities in Island Lake: Village Water, District Sewer

The Village of Island Lake runs its own water system. According to its 2023 plan, the village's system originally served only the newer parts of town, and it took over the older areas when it bought the private Island Lake Water Company in 1995. It has been upgrading those older mains since, which the plan says has raised water pressure, cut main breaks and improved quality. Treatment includes iron removal, softening, chlorination and fluoridation, and the village is studying whether Lake Michigan water could become its primary source.

Sewer is a separate agency. The Northern Moraine Water Reclamation District collects and treats wastewater for Island Lake, Lakemoor and Port Barrington at a plant on Timber Trail west of Roberts Road. The plan lists that plant at 2.0 million gallons a day of capacity with flow around 1.4 million. You pay the district directly; the village cannot take sewer payments. A few properties are still on private wells, which matters for the final water bill at closing and for the inspection.

Electricity is ComEd, gas is Nicor, and garbage and recycling are handled by LRS under a village contract, with Monday pickup. One rule new owners hit quickly: street parking is banned from 2 a.m. to 6 a.m. every day and whenever an inch of snow falls.

Community Resources

Healthcare and Hospitals Near Island Lake

For everyday care, Lake Immediate Care and Clinic at 521 Kora Lane in Island Lake offers primary care and walk-in urgent care. For hospital care, the two closest full-service options are Advocate Good Shepherd Hospital on Route 22 near Barrington and Northwestern Medicine McHenry Hospital in McHenry. Which one is closer depends on which side of the village you are on and which way traffic on 176 is running.

Entertainment & Culture

Things to Do in Island Lake

From May to September life runs on the water: swimming at the village beaches, fishing from a dock, a pontoon out to the island and back. The Fox River is a few minutes west for bigger boats, and the Chain O'Lakes is a short drive north. In winter the lake goes quiet, and ice fishing takes over when conditions allow.

Moraine Hills State Park has trails around Lake Defiance and along the Fox River, and Volo Bog State Natural Area, a few miles north, has a boardwalk through a rare quaking bog. For concerts, theaters and bigger nights out, Crystal Lake, Barrington and Wauconda are all close. My Volo and Lakemoor guides cover the neighbors to the north.

Community Life

Lake Fest and Island Lake's Yearly Calendar

The big one is Lake Fest, and it is in June, not July. According to the village's 2026 events calendar, the 2026 Lake Fest and carnival ran Friday through Sunday, June 12 to 14, at Water Tower Park. Fireworks were July 18, with July 19 as the rain date, separate from the Independence Day parade and community picnic at Converse Park on July 4.

The rest of the year is a steady small-town rhythm: village-wide garage sales the first weekend of June, Concerts in the Park at Converse Park (June 6 and August 22 this year), National Night Out in August, an Oktoberfest at Water Tower Park from September 25 to 27, 2026, Trunk or Treat in late October, a craft fair at Village Hall in November and a tree lighting with a spaghetti dinner in December. A Victory Garden at Veterans Park runs from mid-April to late October.

If you are touring in late September, go to Oktoberfest. It tells you more about the village than any listing will.

Illustration of a lit carnival with rides at dusk in a park, representing Lake Fest at Water Tower Park in Island Lake, Illinois
AI illustration, not a photo of Lake Fest at Water Tower Park.
What's Changing

What's Being Built in Island Lake

Island Lake isn't a boom town, but a few things are moving. The one to watch is Walnut Glen. The agenda for the village board's September 10, 2026 meeting included extending the due-diligence period and moving the closing date to September 30, 2026 for the purchase of 49 vacant acres in Walnut Glen by KLM Builders. Nothing about a site plan was on that agenda, and I haven't seen one. If you are looking at a house backing onto open land in Walnut Glen, ask what that land is.

Other recent approvals are smaller. The village rezoned Sylvan Lakes Estates to R-5 in 2025 and granted special uses in 2026 for 27555 W. Route 176 and 311 E. State Road, according to its ordinance list. The Lakeview Drive bridge over the lake, built in 1975 and rated 49.6 out of 100 in 2021, is slated for replacement with a higher deck for boat passage, but the village's 2023 project sheet left construction timing to funding.

The long-range wild card is Golden Oaks Farm. The village plan describes it as almost 2,500 acres between Route 176 and Volo and between US-12 and the village's western edge, still operated as a livestock breeding farm. Its owners have not signaled any plan to develop, and if they ever do, the plan estimates it could add 8,000 to 10,000 residents across several villages. Nothing is scheduled.

I don't label any town or neighborhood as safe or unsafe.

Illustration of a low bridge over a lake, representing the Lakeview Drive bridge over Island Lake in Island Lake, Illinois
AI illustration, not a photo of the Lakeview Drive bridge over Island Lake.
Before You Buy

Flood Risk and the Rules to Know Before Buying in Island Lake

Flooding is a lot-by-lot question here. Redfin, using First Street's model, rates Island Lake's overall flood risk as minor, with 2% of properties at severe risk over the next 30 years. The low spots near the lake, the creeks and the Fox River are where that risk sits. The village's plan also warns that much of the village sits on wet, hydric soils, which is worth keeping in mind on any basement.

Check the address on the FEMA flood map, because a mapped flood zone can mean required flood insurance on a mortgage, and the village has an "Am I in a Flood Plain?" page for the local maps. Ask the seller about water in the lower level. On a lake lot, ask what shoreline work has been done: properties on the lake, streams and river have to meet the village's shoreline protection code.

A few village rules are specific to Island Lake. According to the village's seller checklist, there is no transfer stamp and no point-of-sale inspection for residential sales (the inspection requirement ended March 25, 2021); the seller calls the village at least 10 business days before closing for a final water bill. Buyers of a house with a gravel driveway get six months to pave it. And if you plan to rent a property out, the village requires it to be registered and inspected before a tenant moves in. My rent vs. buy guide for Lake County covers the other side of that decision.

Quick Answers

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does a house cost in Island Lake, IL?+

Redfin reported a median sale price of $329,682 for the three months ending August 2026, up 9.9% from a year earlier. Zillow's home value index was $309,230 for August 2026, up 6.1%.

What are property taxes in Island Lake, IL?+

Ownwell (April 2026) puts the median effective rate at 2.22% on the Lake County side, with a median bill of $5,218, and 2.38% on the McHenry County side, with a median bill of $5,788. A home's bill usually rises after a sale once it is reassessed.

Is Island Lake in Lake County or McHenry County?+

Both. The village straddles the county line, with the Lake County side in Wauconda Township and the McHenry County side in Nunda Township. The county affects the assessor, the tax bill and sometimes the school district, so check it on every listing.

What school district is Island Lake, IL in?+

Mostly Wauconda Community Unit School District 118, which has Cotton Creek School and Matthews Middle School in the village and Wauconda High School in Wauconda. The village plan says some addresses fall in the McHenry-area Districts 15 and 156, so confirm each address with the district.

How long is the commute from Island Lake to downtown Chicago?+

There is no Metra station in the village. From Cary on the Union Pacific Northwest line, rush-hour express trains reach Ogilvie in about 47 minutes and other trains in about 67, with 27 weekday inbound trains. Add the drive to the station.

Can you swim and boat on Island Lake?+

Yes. The village lists four swim beaches and requires a boat sticker: $20 for a resident's first boat, $15 for each additional and $40 for nonresidents. Horsepower limits apply.

When is Island Lake's Lake Fest?+

In 2026 Lake Fest and its carnival ran June 12 to 14 at Water Tower Park, with fireworks on July 18. Check the village's events calendar for next year's dates.

Is there a grocery store in Island Lake?+

Yes. Lomeli's Fresh Market reopened the former Island Foods building on Route 176 on December 23, 2025, with a butcher counter, bakery and hot deli.

Eshu Chikoti has extensive access to off-market listings throughout Island Lake and the surrounding North Shore — homes that never make it to the public listing sites. That matters right now: in a seller's market like this one, well-priced homes routinely go under contract within days, and buyers relying only on public listings are competing for whatever is left over. Working with someone plugged into off-market inventory means seeing homes before the crowd does.

Eshu Chikoti · 847-691-4282 ·

Nearby Towns

Towns Neighboring Island Lake

Most buyers looking at Island Lake end up touring a couple of the towns next door before they decide. Each of these has a full guide of its own — same depth on schools, commute, taxes, and what the housing stock actually looks like.

Get new Island Lake listings by email

When a home comes on the market in Island Lake, I'll email it to you.

Just your email. Unsubscribe any time by replying.

Thinking About Island Lake?

Whether you're buying, selling, or just curious what's on the market, I can walk you through Island Lake street by street.