Old Mill Creek, IL is a village of about 160 people on nearly 11 square miles of horse country in northern Lake County, where homes sit on acreage with private wells and septic.
Living in Old Mill Creek, IL means acreage, horse farms and forest preserve next door, with I-94 at the edge of the village. The trade-offs are a private well and septic system, no stores or train station in town, and property tax near 2.8% of value. Here is how it works, road by road.
Written by Eshu Chikoti · 847-691-4282 ·

The name comes from a sawmill. According to Wikipedia's village history, a settler named Jacob Miller built a sawmill along a tributary of the Des Plaines River around 1838, and the creek and the settlement around it became Mill Creek. Historians don't agree on the exact year; estimates run from 1835 to 1840.
The area stayed agricultural for more than a century. Schools began appearing around 1840, and the Browe School operated from about 1859 until 1960. A cemetery was established in 1850. When the Chicago, Milwaukee, St. Paul and Pacific Railroad opened a station in nearby Gurnee in 1873, farms here had a way to get goods to Chicago, but the railroad never ran through Mill Creek itself.
The village incorporated in 1959. Old Mill Creek was set up to keep its land in large parcels rather than let it be subdivided the way much of Lake County was in the decades after the war, and that choice is still visible from any road in the village. There is no downtown, no commercial strip and very little of what you would call a subdivision.
The other thread running through the village's history is horses. The Mill Creek Hunt Club began in 1897 as the Onwentsia Hunt on the grounds of the Onwentsia Club in Lake Forest and moved to the Wadsworth area in 1927 under its current name. Its clubhouse, stables and kennels were designed by the architect David Adler, a club member best known for his North Shore estates.
Old Mill Creek covers about 10.85 square miles in northern Lake County, 10.67 of it land, according to Wikipedia. The 2020 Census counted 162 people, down from 178 in 2010, which works out to about 15 people per square mile. That is one of the lowest densities of any incorporated place in the county.
The 2020-2024 Census ACS estimates 77 housing units in the village, with a margin of error of plus or minus 30. With a village this small, every survey number comes with a wide margin, and I treat them as rough sizes rather than precise counts.
The first thing that confuses buyers is the address. Old Mill Creek doesn't have its own post office. Redfin lists homes in the village under five ZIP codes (60083, 60002, 60046, 60031 and 60099), and listings print the mailing town, so an Old Mill Creek house can say Wadsworth, Antioch, Lake Villa or Gurnee on the MLS sheet. If you care whether a property is inside the village, and you should because the zoning, taxes and services follow the municipal line, check the parcel before you trust the town name on the listing.
The village sits between Wadsworth to the east, Gurnee and Lindenhurst to the south and Antioch to the west, with the Wisconsin line a short drive north. I-94 runs along the east side. Warren-Newport Public Library describes its district as covering most of Warren and Newport townships, including Old Mill Creek, which is a useful way to picture where the village sits.
The well, the septic, the driveway, the fencing and the outbuildings are all yours to maintain, and the tax bill on a large parcel is real money.
Old Mill Creek doesn't have neighborhoods the way a suburb does. Buyers and locals describe a property by its road. The main ones are Mill Creek Road, Millburn Road, Hunt Club Road and Wadsworth Road, with I-94, US-45 and Route 173 framing the village. Walk Score names two neighborhoods here, Deane Hill Estates and Hunt Club Farms, and those are the closest thing the village has to subdivisions.
What changes from road to road is the land. Some parcels are open pasture with barns and fencing already in place. Others are wooded, rolling ground with creeks running through, which is the terrain the Mill Creek Hunt Club describes as its hunt country. The rolling land near Pine Dunes Forest Preserve is some of the most varied in the county. I would look at the topography and the drainage on a survey before I looked at the kitchen.
The listings on the market in September 2026 show the range. On Redfin, a five-bedroom, 4,103-square-foot house on Thoroughbred Drive was listed at $725,000, and a four-bedroom Cape Cod on 7 acres on Mill Creek Road, with a two-stall barn with a loft, electricity and water, was listed at $825,000. Neither is a subdivision house in the usual sense, and both are priced as much on land and outbuildings as on square footage.
Boundaries here are informal, and the mailing-address issue means a "Hunt Club Farms" listing can show a Wadsworth address. If you want to know whether a specific property is inside the village, and what similar land has sold for nearby, that is a conversation I am happy to have here.

Mill Creek Road. The village's namesake road, running north to south through the middle of Old Mill Creek. Larger parcels, pasture and barns; the $825,000 7-acre listing in September 2026 was here.
Hunt Club Farms. A named neighborhood Walk Score places in Old Mill Creek; some listings in it carry a Wadsworth mailing address. Custom homes on large lots.
Deane Hill Estates. The other neighborhood Walk Score names in the village. Confirm the lot size and the school assignment for each house.
Thoroughbred Drive. A small cluster of larger custom homes; a five-bedroom house here was listed at $725,000 in September 2026.
Millburn Road. Runs past the Millburn school campus at the south end of the area. Mixed parcel sizes; Redfin recorded a $145,000 sale here in September 2026.
Near Pine Dunes. The northwest part of the area around Hunt Club Road and the forest preserve. Rolling, wooded ground with trail access nearby.
Almost every home in Old Mill Creek is a single-family house on acreage. The village's residential zoning calls for large lots, commonly cited at a two-acre minimum, and many parcels run well past that. You will see farmhouses, Cape Cods and ranches from the middle of the last century, larger custom homes from the 1980s onward, and working horse properties with barns, paddocks and arenas.
The 2020-2024 Census ACS puts the median home value at $450,000, with a margin of error of plus or minus $126,473. That margin is so wide because the survey only reaches a handful of homes here. I would not use it to price anything. It does tell you that the village isn't only estates.
What sets these houses apart is the equipment you inherit. A horse property can come with a barn, fencing, a well that serves the barn as well as the house, a manure plan, and outbuildings that need their own roofs and electrical. Buyers from the suburbs tend to budget for the house and forget the rest. On a property like the Mill Creek Road listing, with a two-stall barn and a heated three-car garage, I would inspect the outbuildings as carefully as the home.
For any older house here, plan for a well test, a septic inspection and a look at the drainage, on top of the usual inspection. My home inspection checklist is a good place to start, and I add a rural section to it for properties like these.

Here is the honest answer about prices in Old Mill Creek: there aren't enough sales to produce a reliable village median. Redfin's Old Mill Creek market page, checked in September 2026, still shows its last village-level median from the three months ending October 2021. Any single number you see quoted for the village, including the one on the older version of this page, is a handful of sales at most.
What Redfin does publish is its Compete Score, calculated over the last 12 months. It rates Old Mill Creek 26 out of 100, which it calls not very competitive. Homes typically sell about 5% below list price and go pending in around 62 days, and Redfin says multiple offers are rare. That fits what I would expect for acreage properties. The buyer pool for a horse farm is small, and the right buyer takes time to find.
Recent activity gives you a sense of the range. In September 2026 Redfin listed a five-bedroom on Thoroughbred Drive at $725,000 and a 7-acre property with a barn on Mill Creek Road at $825,000. The most recent sale Redfin shows with an Old Mill Creek address closed on Millburn Road on September 10, 2026, for $145,000, after 302 days on the market and 27% under its list price. For comparison, Ownwell puts the median home value at $564,290 for the 60083 ZIP it uses for the village, as of April 2026.
The nearby market is easier to read. In Wadsworth, which shares the 60083 ZIP, Redfin reported a median sale price of $545,889 in the three months ending August 2026. Old Mill Creek's larger parcels usually price above that. For the county picture, see my Lake County market report for Q3 2026.
What that means in practice: pricing a property here is a comparable-sales exercise across the whole area, weighted for acreage, outbuildings and condition. A seller who lists off a Zestimate or an old village median usually ends up in that 5%-below-list group.
Property tax is the carrying cost that surprises buyers most here, because the parcels are large and the listing price doesn't show it. Ownwell's April 2026 data puts Old Mill Creek's median effective property tax rate at 2.82%, against 2.61% for Lake County as a whole, with a median annual bill of $15,800. Across the 60083 ZIP, the middle half of bills runs from $8,588 to $19,623.
Here is what that looks like on a real listing. At 2.82%, the $725,000 Thoroughbred Drive house would eventually carry about $20,400 a year in tax, roughly $1,700 a month on top of the mortgage. The current bill may be lower because assessments trail the market, but the assessor catches up, usually in the reassessment year after a sale. The expectation I most often have to reset is buyers who budget off the seller's current bill.
Two things are particular to Old Mill Creek. First, the tax code depends on which school, fire, library and township bodies serve a parcel, and with two elementary-and-middle districts possible in this area, two neighbors can carry different rates. Second, land used for farming may be assessed differently from residential land. If a property you like has hay fields or pasture, ask what the parcel is assessed as and whether that continues after the sale.
If you already own here and think your assessment is high, my Lake County property tax appeal guide walks through the process and the deadlines. This is general information, not tax advice. Your actual bill depends on your parcel, your exemptions and the assessor.
Most of Old Mill Creek is served by Millburn Community Consolidated School District 24, which lists Wadsworth, Old Mill Creek and Lindenhurst as the communities it serves. The district runs two schools: Millburn Elementary School at 18550 Millburn Road, which has a Wadsworth mailing address and serves early childhood through fifth grade, and Millburn Middle School at 640 Freedom Way in Lindenhurst for grades six through eight. The elementary building also hosts classrooms from the Special Education District of Lake County.
For high school, the older version of this page and the neighboring Wadsworth district list point to Warren Township High School District 121, one high school on two campuses in Gurnee: the O'Plaine Campus for grades nine and ten and the Almond Campus for grades eleven and twelve. Some Millburn-area listings instead name Lakes Community High School in District 117, so the high school depends on the parcel.
Confirm the district for a specific address with the district office, and read each district's profile on the Illinois Report Card at illinoisreportcard.com.
The detail that trips people up is assignment, and it's worse here than in most towns because of the mailing addresses. A house with an Antioch or Lake Villa address can still be in Millburn, and the listing's school fields are not always right. Check the address with the district directly before you write an offer, and ask me for the boundary if you want it done for a specific house.

Millburn Elementary School. 18550 Millburn Road (Wadsworth mailing address). Early childhood through grade 5, District 24; also the district office.
Millburn Middle School. 640 Freedom Way, Lindenhurst. Grades 6–8, District 24.
Warren Township High School, O'Plaine Campus. 500 N. O'Plaine Road, Gurnee. Grades 9 and 10, District 121.
Warren Township High School, Almond Campus. 34090 N. Almond Road, Gurnee. Grades 11 and 12, District 121.
Lakes Community High School. 1600 Eagle Way, Lake Villa. District 117, for parcels assigned there.
Old Mill Creek has no train station, and no rail line runs through the village. A train commute starts with a drive, and there are two directions to go.
West, the Antioch and Lake Villa stations are on Metra's North Central Service, a one-seat ride to Union Station. According to Metra's current NCS schedule, seven trains leave Antioch for Chicago each weekday and seven come back, with no weekend or holiday service. The fastest morning train reaches Union Station in about 92 minutes from Antioch; most take 98 to 103. The last outbound train leaves Union Station at 6:00 p.m.
East, the Waukegan station on the Union Pacific North line has more service. Metra's UP-N schedule shows 26 inbound trains on weekdays and 15 each way on weekends, with the morning rush trains reaching Ogilvie Transportation Center in about 70 minutes and most others in 80.
Add the drive and parking, and a door-to-desk commute to the Loop from Old Mill Creek runs well past 90 minutes each way. Most people here don't make it daily. The 2020-2024 ACS puts the average one-way commute at 23.4 minutes, plus or minus 4.7, which points to jobs in Lake County, Kenosha County and along I-94.

Driving is where Old Mill Creek does well for a rural village. Wikipedia lists I-94 (the Tri-State Tollway), US-45 and Route 173 as the main roads through the area. I-94 runs along the east side of the village, so Kenosha and Milwaukee are an easy drive north and the rest of Lake County is an easy drive south. Route 173 connects west to Antioch and east to Zion, and US-45 runs south toward Lindenhurst and Grayslake.
Inside the village, the roads are two-lane and rural. Mill Creek Road, Millburn Road, Hunt Club Road and Wadsworth Road carry most local traffic. Expect farm equipment in season, riders and horse trailers on weekends, and roads that the county and township plow after the main routes. If a property has a long private driveway, ask who plows it and what it costs; that line item doesn't exist in a subdivision.
For daily errands, the drive is to Gurnee, Antioch or Lindenhurst. O'Hare is reached by I-94 and the Tri-State, and the trip is long enough that I tell buyers who fly often to time it at rush hour before they commit.
No, and it isn't meant to be. Walk Score counts about three restaurants, bars and coffee shops in the whole village, and says residents can walk to an average of 0.0 of them in five minutes. Every errand is a drive.
What the village has instead is trail. Pine Dunes Forest Preserve, on the village's northwest side, has trails open to hiking, bicycling, cross-country skiing and horseback riding, and they connect along Russell Road to the Des Plaines River Trail at Van Patten Woods. The Mill Creek Hunt Club's members ride across more than 6,000 acres of private land. If walking or riding for recreation matters more to you than walking to a coffee shop, Old Mill Creek does better than its Walk Score suggests.
There is no retail district in Old Mill Creek, and that is by design. The village has kept its land in large parcels since it incorporated, and commercial development hasn't been part of that plan.
The big shopping trip is to Gurnee. Gurnee Mills, the Simon-owned mall on Grand Avenue that opened in 1991, has about 1.94 million square feet of leasable space, a mix of outlet and full-price stores, and a movie theater. Big-box stores cluster around it and along Route 173 and Grand Avenue. Kenosha's retail along I-94 is a similar drive for the north end of the village. For farm and horse supplies, most owners here build their own list of feed stores and tack shops across northern Lake and southern Kenosha counties.
There is no grocery store in the village. Most people shop in Gurnee, where full-service supermarkets and discount grocers line Grand Avenue, Route 21 and Washington Street, or in Antioch, where Jewel-Osco has a full store with a pharmacy at 966 Route 59 and Aldi and Shop & Save Market are on Route 173. For a large stock-up trip, Woodman's and Meijer in Kenosha are a short drive north.
The practical advice I give buyers moving from a suburb: a weekly trip replaces the quick run to the store, and a chest freezer earns its space here.
Walk Score counts about three restaurants, bars and coffee shops inside Old Mill Creek's boundary, which is a very small number for a place this size. For a real choice of restaurants, people head to Gurnee, where the Grand Avenue and I-94 corridor is lined with restaurants serving Six Flags and Gurnee Mills visitors and local places cluster along Washington Street and Old Grand Avenue. Antioch's downtown on Main Street and Lindenhurst's shopping centers are the other short drives.
Pine Dunes Forest Preserve is the village's big outdoor asset. The Lake County Forest Preserves list it at 956 acres, with its entrance at 42909 Hunt Club Road (an Antioch mailing address), open daily from 6:30 a.m. to sunset. It has 2.8 miles of gravel trails, four boardwalks, three scenic overlooks, drinking water and a toilet, and the trails are open to hiking, bicycling, cross-country skiing and horseback riding. Dogs must be leashed.
The forest preserve district describes Pine Dunes as having some of the finest rolling topography in Lake County: prairie, savanna and oak-hickory woodland, with streams, marshes, sedge meadows and vernal ponds. About 70% of it is upland and 30% wetland. In a 2013 agreement tied to the O'Hare Western Access project, the Illinois Tollway restored 80 acres of wetland and 235 acres of savanna and prairie here.
Pine Dunes is one of five preserves and a state natural area that make up a 5,300-acre trail and greenway along the Wisconsin line. Its trails connect along Russell Road to the Des Plaines River Trail at Van Patten Woods in Wadsworth, and the forest preserve district plans to link them to the regional Millennium Trail as well.
The village has no park district of its own. For pools, playgrounds and organized programs, residents use neighboring park districts, often at non-resident rates, so check the fees before you count on a program.

Old Mill Creek doesn't run its own library, but it isn't without one. The Warren-Newport Public Library District names Old Mill Creek in its service area, along with Gurnee, Wadsworth, Park City, Wildwood and Grandwood Park. The district serves about 67,000 people across 55 square miles from its library at 224 O'Plaine Road in Gurnee.
Some parcels at the edges of the village can fall in a different library district, which also shows up on the tax bill. If a library card matters to you, confirm the district for the specific address.
Old Mill Creek has no municipal water or sewer. Homes run on private wells and septic systems, and that single fact shapes more of the purchase than anything else on this page.
On a well, you are your own water utility. Before closing I have buyers order a water test through a certified lab, and many lenders require one. Ask the seller for the well's age and depth, the last pump replacement and any treatment equipment, and budget for a softener or filter if the test calls for one. On a horse property, find out whether the barn runs on the same well as the house.
On septic, the system is only as good as its last inspection. Ask for the pumping records and the permit on file with the Lake County Health Department, and have the system inspected, not just pumped. A replacement field on an acreage lot is a five-figure line item, and the lot's soils decide what kind of system you can put back.
Electricity comes from ComEd. Natural gas isn't available on every road, so some homes run on propane; ask which one the house uses and what last winter cost. High-speed internet varies by road, so check the providers for the exact address before you rely on working from home.
Old Mill Creek has no hospital or clinic. For inpatient and specialty care, most people use Advocate Condell Medical Center in Libertyville to the south, and Kenosha's hospitals are a similar drive for the north end of the village. Gurnee has outpatient imaging and immediate care along Hunt Club Road.
Two recent changes matter if you are relying on an older guide. Vista Health System's freestanding emergency room in Lindenhurst closed permanently on July 15, 2024, though the campus still offers outpatient services. And Vista Medical Center East in Waukegan has been in financial trouble, with employees reporting bounced paychecks in September 2026. If a specific hospital matters to you, check its current status and your insurance network before you buy.
Emergency response is the other thing to confirm. According to Wikipedia, fire protection has come from Wadsworth since the 1960s. The fire protection district for a parcel appears on the tax bill, and response time on a long rural driveway is a fair question to ask.
The village's culture is horses. The Mill Creek Hunt Club, active since 1897, rides with hounds across more than 6,000 acres of rolling, wooded farmland divided by creeks, on land owned by three major landowners who allow members and guests to ride it. Pre-season starts in early August and runs to the Opening Meet, the annual Blessing of the Hounds, in late September. Formal hunting continues through mid-December, weather permitting.
The area is also known for Tempel Farms and its Lipizzan horses. Wikipedia lists the Tempel Farms Lipizzan horses as part of the Wadsworth community, and notes that founder Tempel Smith's farm was in Spring Grove in 1958, before the move to this area. The Haflinger article credits the same Tempel Smith with importing Haflinger horses from Austria that year. For decades the farm staged public performances of classical horsemanship. Its public schedule has changed in recent years, so check with the farm directly before you plan a visit.
For bigger outings, Six Flags Great America and Gurnee Mills are in Gurnee, and Kenosha's lakefront is a short drive north. If you are also looking east, my guide to living in Gurnee covers the town most Old Mill Creek errands run through.

Old Mill Creek doesn't hold village festivals. Its calendar follows the hunt. The Mill Creek Hunt Club's events page lists the year: hound exercise and a puppy show at the club in July, the Opening Meet in September, the fall and formal season from August through December, and the Hunt Ball in November. Members also travel to the Midwest Horse Fair in April and the Virginia Hound Show in May. The club publishes its exact dates in a yearly fixture card.
For public events, residents go next door. Wadsworth's annual Concert in the Park and Gurnee Days in Gurnee are the nearest, and the Lake County Forest Preserves run seasonal hikes and restoration workdays at Pine Dunes. If you want to understand a village this small before you buy in it, the forest preserve workdays and a village board meeting will tell you more than any listing.
Old Mill Creek changes slowly, and I found no active subdivision or commercial project in the village this year. The most recent public record I could find involving the village is on Wadsworth's side. In April 2026 the Wadsworth Plan Commission heard a request to remove zoning provisions tied to an expired intergovernmental agreement between Wadsworth, Old Mill Creek and Lake County over the Route 173 and I-94 interchange. That agreement shaped how the land around the interchange could develop. With it expired, what happens near that interchange is worth watching if you are looking at property on the east side of the village.
Next door, road work continues. Wadsworth's board made final payment on its North Mill Creek Road improvement project in September 2026.
For a buyer, the practical point is that the large-lot pattern isn't under pressure. New construction here usually means a custom home on an existing parcel. The village's own website was under construction when I checked in September 2026, so ask the village clerk directly for current zoning and permit rules. I track what comes before the nearby boards; if you are weighing a property near Route 173 or I-94, ask me what is pending here.
I don't label any town or neighborhood as safe or unsafe.
Flooding in Old Mill Creek is a parcel-by-parcel question. Redfin, using First Street's model, rates the village's flood risk as moderate, with 12 properties, about 6%, at risk of severe flooding over the next 30 years. That risk sits along the creeks and the low, wet ground near them, which on a large parcel can mean part of the land floods while the house is fine.
First Street also rates wildfire risk as moderate, with 97% of properties at some risk over 30 years. That number sounds alarming, but on open prairie and woodland it mostly reflects grass and brush fire potential, which is worth knowing if you have hay stored in a barn.
Two checks before you write an offer. Look the address up on the FEMA flood map, because a mapped flood zone can mean required flood insurance on a mortgage. And walk the property after a heavy rain if you can, or ask the seller where the water goes. On acreage, the answer to that question tells you where you can and can't build a barn, an arena or a new septic field.
There are too few sales for a reliable village median; Redfin's last one dates to 2021. In September 2026 Redfin listed a five-bedroom on Thoroughbred Drive at $725,000 and a 7-acre property with a barn on Mill Creek Road at $825,000.
The median effective rate is about 2.82%, with a median bill of about $15,800 (Ownwell, April 2026). Rates vary by tax code, and a home's bill usually rises after a sale once it is reassessed.
Most of the village is in Millburn CCSD 24 for early childhood through eighth grade. High school is Warren Township High School District 121 or, for some parcels, Lakes Community High School in District 117. Confirm each address with the districts.
No. The closest options are the Antioch and Lake Villa stations on the North Central Service (seven weekday trains each way, no weekends) and the Waukegan station on the Union Pacific North line (26 weekday inbound trains).
No. Homes run on private wells and septic systems. Test the well and have the septic inspected, not just pumped, before you buy.
The village zones for large residential lots, commonly cited at two acres, and many parcels are much larger. Confirm the rule for a specific parcel with the village before you plan to divide land or build.
A foxhunting club that began in 1897 as the Onwentsia Hunt in Lake Forest and moved to the Wadsworth area in 1927. Members ride across more than 6,000 acres, with the season opening at the Blessing of the Hounds in late September.
Pine Dunes Forest Preserve (956 acres, 42909 Hunt Club Road) has 2.8 miles of trails open to hiking, biking, skiing and horseback riding, connecting along Russell Road to the Des Plaines River Trail at Van Patten Woods.
Eshu Chikoti has extensive access to off-market listings throughout Old Mill Creek and the surrounding North Shore — homes that never make it to the public listing sites. That matters right now: in a seller's market like this one, well-priced homes routinely go under contract within days, and buyers relying only on public listings are competing for whatever is left over. Working with someone plugged into off-market inventory means seeing homes before the crowd does.
Eshu Chikoti · 847-691-4282 ·
Most buyers looking at Old Mill Creek end up touring a couple of the towns next door before they decide. Each of these has a full guide of its own — same depth on schools, commute, taxes, and what the housing stock actually looks like.
Get new Old Mill Creek listings by email
When a home comes on the market in Old Mill Creek, I'll email it to you.
Just your email. Unsubscribe any time by replying.
Whether you're buying, selling, or just curious what's on the market, I can walk you through Old Mill Creek street by street.