Neighborhood Guide

McCullom Lake, IL

McCullom Lake, IL is a McHenry County village of about 1,000 people packed onto a third of a square mile on the north shore of a shallow, 244-acre lake it shares with the City of McHenry, where the houses are small and old and the sewer, the well and the lake matter as much as the kitchen.

Living in McCullom Lake, IL means a typical home value near $236,000, property tax around 2.43% of value, and a small village beach and launch on a lake the City of McHenry mostly owns. The trade-offs: older houses on small lots, private wells, a sewer hookup required at sale, and a lake with phosphorus problems.

Written by Eshu Chikoti · 847-691-4282 ·

Illustration of a lake at sunset from a small village beach with a wooded far shore, representing McCullom Lake from the village park and beach in McCullom Lake, Illinois
AI illustration, not a photo of McCullom Lake from the village park and beach.
Commute to Chicago (Metra)
McHenry station ≈ 1.8 mi; 82 min, 3 weekday trains
Typical Home Value
≈ $236K (Zillow, Aug 2026)
Public Schools
McHenry D15 + McHenry D156
Highway Access
IL Routes 31 and 120
Property Tax
≈ 2.43% effective
The Lake
244 acres, 9.5 ft max depth, mostly City of McHenry owned
Full In-Depth Guide
Background

How McCullom Lake, IL Got Here: From Slough to Summer Cottages

The lake came first and the village came much later. According to the 1992 Clean Lakes diagnostic study of McCullom Lake, prepared by the Northeastern Illinois Planning Commission with the City of McHenry and the Illinois EPA, the lake is named after William McCullom, who came to McHenry from Virginia in 1837 and settled on the western shore with his brothers John and David. At the time it was a shallow, marshy glacial lake known as McCullom Slough. A dam built at the outlet around 1890 raised the water about a foot and a half, and from then on it was McCullom Lake.

The same study tells the story of the houses. During the 1930s and 1940s many summer cottages went up as city residents came out to the lakes northwest of Chicago, and most of those cottages were later converted to year-round homes. The earliest aerial photo the study found, from 1939, already showed all the streets of what is now the village, and a 1954 aerial showed the village built out nearly to the extent it had in 1992. That is the single most useful fact about McCullom Lake housing: almost everything here was laid out before 1955.

The village incorporated on April 7, 1955, according to Wikipedia's village article, which lists census counts of 759 in 1960, 1,033 in 1990, 1,049 in 2010 and 988 in 2020. The population has barely moved in 60 years because there is almost no room left to build.

The lake itself changed hands in 1984. The 1992 study says a local conservation club did most of the lake management from 1966 until 1984, including dredging in the western part of the lake from 1979 to 1982, and that in 1984 the City of McHenry acquired most of the lake bottom and took over jurisdiction. That is why the lake today is managed mainly by the city next door, not by the village that carries its name.

The Basics

McCullom Lake at a Glance

McCullom Lake is a tiny village on the north shore of the lake, bordered by the City of McHenry to the south and east and by Ringwood Road to the west. McCullom Lake Road runs along its north edge. The 2020 Census Gazetteer figures on Wikipedia put the village at 0.36 square miles, almost all of it land, and it sits in McHenry Township. The mailing address is McHenry, IL 60050, the same ZIP code as much of the City of McHenry.

That shared address is the first thing to sort out on any listing. A house that says "McHenry 60050" in the lake area can be in the village, in the city, or in unincorporated county land along the west shore. The 1992 lake study counted 92 homes on the shoreline: 51 in the City of McHenry along the south shore, 11 in the village along the northwest shore, and 30 in unincorporated county land to the northwest and west. Each of those has a different set of services, rules and tax lines.

The 2020-2024 Census ACS estimates 1,017 people and 438 housing units in the village. For a place this small the survey's margins of error are wide, so treat every ACS number on this page as a rough guide rather than a count. The 2020 census itself counted 988 people.

Village or not changes a lot here. Inside the village you have the village police, a mandatory village sewer with its own rules at sale, a vehicle sticker, on-street parking permits and a building inspector who wants a permit for nearly everything. I check the parcel's municipality on the county records before anything else on a McCullom Lake house.

Zillow's August 2026 index was $236,382 here, against $291,107 in Wonder Lake, $315,402 in McHenry and $409,057 in Johnsburg.

The houses are small and old, the lake is shallow and nutrient-rich, most homes are on private wells, and the sewer, sticker and permit rules take real attention at closing and after.

McCullom Lake limits outlined in navy (U.S. Census Bureau); Metra stations in gold (Metra). Drag to move, + and − to zoom.
The Water

McCullom Lake Itself: Shallow, Shared and Mostly City-Owned

McCullom Lake is a small, shallow glacial lake. The 1992 diagnostic study measured it at 244 acres with 2.45 miles of shoreline, a maximum depth of 9.5 feet, a mean depth of 4.4 feet and an average retention time of 254 days. It has no major tributary; much of its water comes from groundwater seeping in from the sand and gravel aquifer on the west and north sides. It drains to a tributary of Dutch Creek and on to the Fox River.

Ownership is the part most buyers get wrong. The same study lists the lake bottom as 86.1% owned by the City of McHenry, 4.5% by the Village of McCullom Lake and 9.4% by others. The Illinois DNR fisheries summary says private residences surround about 80% of the shoreline and that the lake is managed under a cooperative agreement with the IDNR, with the City of McHenry as the local contact. So the lake is public in the sense that it has public parks and launches, but it is not a village amenity you control by living here.

The shallowness shapes everything else. IDNR says the lake is prone to fish kills and carp problems, that heavy aquatic vegetation in summer and fall can make it hard to fish, and that an aerator runs periodically through the winter, so ice anglers should watch for open water. In January 2026 the village's own ice fishing derby was cancelled because of open standing water on the lake, according to the January 27, 2026 board minutes.

If you are buying on the water, plan on a lake that is best for small boats, paddling, fishing and winter ice, not for waterskiing. That is not a knock on it. It is what a four-foot lake is.

Illustration of a small boat on a calm lake, typical of McCullom Lake, Illinois
Illustrative image, not a photo of this exact spot.
Before You Buy

McCullom Lake Access: Village Beach, Boat Posts and the 10-Horsepower Limit

Village residents get lake access through the village park and beach, not through deeded rights on each lot. According to the village's resident guide, the park opens at 6 a.m. and closes at 10 p.m., there are no dogs, alcohol or motorized vehicles on the beach or in the park, and swimming is at your own risk. The beach opens each season once the village receives its state beach facility license; the May 26, 2026 minutes record that the village had just received its beach facility license and would open the beach that Friday.

Boat storage is limited. The village's 2026 boating rules allow 22 boats to be left at the launch site at $20 per post for April 1 to October 31, or $40 for a year-round permit renewable before April 1. Residents can have no more than two posts. A key to the launch gate costs $5 a year and must be returned by November 1, and the lock changes every year. Boats are limited to 14 feet and 10 horsepower, or 25 horsepower for pontoons, and the resident guide adds a flat "no jet skis." There is no parking on the road to the launch.

The City of McHenry runs the other access points. Its Lakeland Park Boat Launch at 4904 Shore Drive is a free launch with the same 10 horsepower limit for standard boats and 25 for pontoons, and limited parking on the grass. Petersen Park on the northeast shore has the city beach, boat rentals including canoes, kayaks and paddleboards, and a shelter you can rent.

For a buyer this means two things. Lakefront in the village gets you the view and your own shoreline, but the horsepower rules still apply to you. And a house a few streets back uses the same lake through the village launch and beach, which is a big part of why buyers look here instead of paying lakefront prices elsewhere.

Illustration of a small lake boat launch and boat posts, typical of McCullom Lake, Illinois
Illustrative image, not a photo of this exact spot.

Village park and beach. North shore, 6 a.m. to 10 p.m., no dogs, alcohol or motorized vehicles. Opens once the state beach license arrives each spring.

Village launch and boat posts. Gated launch with a $5 annual key; 22 posts at $20 a season or $40 a year; two posts per resident at most.

Lakeland Park Boat Launch (City of McHenry). 4904 Shore Drive. Free, 10 hp limit for standard boats, 25 hp for pontoons.

Petersen Park (City of McHenry). 4300 Petersen Park Road on the northeast shore. City beach, boat rentals and shelter rentals.

Before You Buy

McCullom Lake Water Quality: Phosphorus, Beach Closures and Carp

The honest summary is that McCullom Lake is a nutrient-rich, shallow lake, and the state has said so for years. In the Illinois EPA's 2026 draft assessment of lakes-list/Appendix%20A-2.%20Specific%20Assessment%20Information%20for%20Lakes,%202026.pdf), McCullom Lake is rated fully supporting for aquatic life but not supporting its aesthetic quality use, with total phosphorus as the cause. It is on the state's 303(d) list of impaired waters for the same reason, at medium priority.

The phosphorus problem is not new. The 1992 study found that every home in the village, and many to the west and northwest, was on a septic system at the time, that about half the soils in the watershed pose severe limits for septic systems, and that the water table near the lake is often within five feet of the surface. It singled out septic effluent as a nutrient source. The village's public sewer, finished in 2003, was the fix for that, but decades of phosphorus in the sediment do not leave a shallow lake quickly.

Beach closures are occasional, not constant. The state's BeachGuard record for the village park and beach shows a one-day closure for high bacteria levels on August 13, 2026, and another on August 20, 2025. The City of McHenry's Petersen Park beach was closed by its operator for the rest of the 2026 season on August 3.

The fishery reflects the same conditions. IDNR stocks largemouth bass and channel catfish, about 1,600 catfish a year, and reports that yellow bass and yellow perch can become so abundant they stunt. At the March 24, 2026 village board meeting, a resident reported too many carp and said the DNR would electrofish them if volunteers could haul the fish out.

My advice: swim when the beach is open, check BeachGuard after heavy rain, and price a lakefront house on what the lake is, not on a photo from June.

Illustration of shallow weedy lake shoreline with a beach-rules post in late summer, representing the village beach and shoreline at McCullom Lake in McCullom Lake, Illinois
AI illustration, not a photo of the village beach and shoreline at McCullom Lake.
Where to Look

McCullom Lake Neighborhoods: The Village and the Subdivisions Around the Lake

Inside the village there are no named subdivisions to speak of. It is one grid of short streets that was already platted by 1939, sloping down from McCullom Lake Road to the water. The streets you will see on listings include Orchard Drive, where the village hall sits at 4811 W. Orchard Drive, Parkview Drive, Maple Hill Drive, Fountain Lane, East Lane, West Lane, West Lakeshore Drive, Spring Road, Forest View, West End and Hickory Drive. Three of the eight sales Redfin listed for the village between April and early September 2026 were on Parkview Drive.

The real choice is between the village and the lake subdivisions around it. The 1992 lake study names the ones within half a mile of the water: Flanders, Johnson, West Shore Beach, Spojnia Park, Brittany Park, Lakeland Park, Lakewood and Lakeland Shores, plus Martin Woods to the northwest. Lakeland Park along the south shore is in the City of McHenry and was the only area around the lake on sanitary sewer in 1992, with lines from the late 1960s. West Shore Beach, on the west side, had roads by 1939 and most of its cottages by 1954. Martin Woods I dates to the late 1970s.

Topography also splits the area. The study describes flat, poorly drained ground along the east and south shores and steeper, better-drained land to the north and west, with slopes averaging about 4% through the village. On a walkthrough that shows up as basements and crawl spaces. The low side is where I ask the most questions about water.

If you want to know whether a specific address is in the village, what utilities it has and what nearby houses actually sold for, that is a conversation I am happy to have here.

The village grid. Orchard, Parkview, Maple Hill, Fountain, East and West Lane, West Lakeshore, Spring, Forest View, West End and Hickory. Village sewer, private wells, village police.

Lakeland Park. South shore, in the City of McHenry. On city sanitary sewer since the late 1960s, per the 1992 study. The city's free boat launch is on Shore Drive.

West Shore Beach. West side of the lake. Roads by 1939 and most cottages by 1954. Redfin tracks it as a separate neighborhood.

Flanders, Johnson and Spojnia Park. West and northwest of the village toward Ringwood Road. Check the parcel's municipality; parts of this area have been discussed for annexation.

Martin Woods and Brittany Park. Newer, lower-density subdivisions to the northwest and west, from the late 1970s on, per the 1992 study.

Lakewood. East shore near Petersen Park, on flat, low ground.

Homes

What McCullom Lake Homes Look Like: Converted Cottages on Small Lots

McCullom Lake housing is almost all small, older single-family homes. The 2020-2024 ACS counts 411 of the village's 438 housing units as detached single-family houses, puts the median year built at 1959, and estimates that 87 were built before 1940, 71 in the 1940s and 67 in the 1950s. Those estimates carry wide margins at this size, but they match the aerial photo record in the 1992 study: the village was built out by 1954.

Lots are small by McHenry County standards. The village's zoning code sets the R-1 district, which applies to the lots platted at the original incorporation, at a minimum of 6,250 square feet with a width of at least 70 feet at the building line, a 30-foot front yard and a 30-foot rear yard. The larger districts start at 10,890 square feet in R-2, 20,000 in R-3 and one acre in R-4. Many older lots predate those rules, so expect nonconforming lots and tight setbacks when you plan an addition or a garage.

Renting is more common here than in most lake villages. The ACS estimates 297 owner-occupied and 113 renter-occupied homes, and the village says in its 2015 rental ordinance that it has a proportionately high number of rental units. Every rental needs a village inspection every two years ($100 the first time, $75 after), a yearly landlord reporting form and a signed lease on file with each change of tenant.

Prices reflect the size. The ACS puts the median owner-occupied value at $178,600 and median gross rent at $1,443, both lagging today's market. What I tell buyers on these converted cottages: expect additions of different ages stacked together, low basements or crawl spaces, older electrical and a well that nobody has tested in years. None of that should end a deal. All of it belongs in the price, and my home inspection checklist is a good place to start.

Illustration of a converted lake cottage and an updated ranch home, typical of McCullom Lake, Illinois
Illustrative image, not a photo of this exact spot.
The Real Estate Market

The McCullom Lake Housing Market in 2026

McCullom Lake is one of the smallest markets I cover, and that changes how you read the numbers. In the three months ending August 2026, Redfin reported a median sale price of $175,000, down 25.6% from a year earlier, a median price per square foot of $195, and 75 days on market against 27 a year before. It counted 3 sales in August 2026, down from 5. Redfin gives the village a Compete Score of 51 out of 100, which it calls somewhat competitive.

Those percentages move on a handful of houses. Redfin's recent-sales list for the village shows eight closings between April 30 and September 2, 2026, from $55,000 to $325,000, and several of them sold over asking. When one small cottage and one updated ranch close in the same month, the median swings by tens of thousands of dollars. I would not read a trend into a 25% drop built on three sales.

Zillow's home value index, which estimates the value of all homes whether they sold or not, is steadier. It was $236,382 for McCullom Lake in August 2026, up 5.2% from $224,715 a year earlier and up 15.1% from $205,434 in August 2024. For comparison, the same index was $315,402 in McHenry, $291,107 in Wonder Lake and $409,057 in Johnsburg. McCullom Lake is the least expensive way into a lake community in this part of the county.

One more caution on geography. Redfin's climate data counts about 623 properties in its McCullom Lake area, well above the 438 housing units the Census counts in the village, so its market numbers may include homes just outside the village line. For a single house, the comparables that matter are nearby sales with the same utilities and the same distance to the water. If you are comparing towns, my McHenry guide and Wonder Lake guide cover the two lake markets on either side.

Typical home value
 
Source: Zillow Home Value Index, all homes, smoothed and seasonally adjusted.
The Real Estate Market

McCullom Lake Property Taxes and the Real Cost of Owning

Property tax in McCullom Lake runs close to the McHenry County rate on low home values. Ownwell's data, updated April 13, 2026, puts the median effective rate at 2.43% and the median annual bill at $3,967, on a median assessor market value of $167,403. That compares with a McHenry County median of 2.42% and an Illinois median of 2.33%. Bills spread from $3,275 at the 25th percentile to $4,898 at the 75th.

Here is what that looks like on a real purchase. At 2.43%, a house worth Zillow's August 2026 typical value of $236,382 would carry about $5,740 a year in tax, roughly $480 a month on top of the mortgage. The seller's current bill may be lower, because assessments trail the market and a sale usually brings a reassessment. The expectation I most often have to reset is buyers who budget off the seller's bill instead of the rate.

Then add the sewer. It is not on the tax bill, but it is a fixed monthly cost of owning here, covered in the next section. The village's own share of the property tax bill is small. At the August 5, 2026 zoning hearing, the village attorney put it at typically about 4% of the total, and in November 2025 the board abated the property tax levy for its 2021 bonds, according to the November 25, 2025 minutes. School districts are most of the bill, as they are across Illinois.

If you already own and think your assessment is high, the appeal goes to the McHenry Township assessor and then the McHenry County Board of Review, and the window depends on when the township's assessments publish. This is general information, not tax advice. Your actual bill depends on your parcel, your exemptions and the assessor.

Before You Buy

Sewer, Wells and the Hookup Rule at Sale in McCullom Lake

This is the section that matters most on a McCullom Lake purchase. The village finished its public sanitary sewer in 2003, according to the village's resident guide. Wastewater goes to the City of McHenry's treatment plant under an intergovernmental agreement, and the village pays the city for each user and each connection, according to the village's 2025 audit.pdf).

The rule to know is in the village code. Section 14-27 says that on any transfer of property on or after November 1, 2003, with or without payment, the new owner must connect to the village sewer within 90 days of closing. The buyer is supposed to complete the building sewer application and pay the $250 permit fee before closing, and the village will issue a "connection letter" confirming compliance. Missing it costs $100 a day from the date of transfer. There is a narrow exemption for moving a property into a trust the prior owner fully controls. The same chapter bans new septic tanks and cesspools where the sewer is available.

So on every village house I ask one question early: is it already connected? If the answer is no, the connection cost belongs in the negotiation, and the application belongs on the closing checklist. At the September 23, 2025 board meeting, the village president described the agreement with McHenry as having made septic fields illegal in the village.

Sewer bills are monthly. The resident guide lists a $25 operation and maintenance charge for every property with a stub, plus treatment charges passed through to the City of McHenry for connected homes, based on the number of people in the home. The village's older "How do I" page still shows $39 for debt reduction and $20 for maintenance, so ask the village office for the current figure. Unpaid sewer bills become a lien on the property after 60 days under Section 14-42, so have the title company ask for a final reading and payoff.

Water is a different story. The village has no public water system for homes. When the McHenry County Health Department sampled the village in May 2010, it tested 13 private wells, one non-community public supply and one surface water sample. The Forest Glen developer's plan to bring in City of McHenry water would stop at that project, and the village president said at the August 2026 hearing that city water will not be available to village residents. Test the well on every purchase.

Before You Buy

The McCullom Lake Groundwater Case: What the Record Shows

If you search McCullom Lake, you will find the lawsuits, so here is the public record in plain terms. Two industrial sites in neighboring Ringwood, the Rohm and Haas (Morton International) plant and Modine Manufacturing, had known groundwater contamination and were in the Illinois EPA's voluntary cleanup program, according to a May 2006 McHenry County Health Department overview. Starting in April 2006, residents of the McCullom Lake area filed suits claiming that air and groundwater contamination from the Rohm and Haas plant caused brain tumors, as reported by the Northwest Herald. The company denied that contamination reached or harmed residents.

The agencies' findings are on the record too. In an October 2006 letter, the Illinois Department of Public Health said nine private wells sampled in May 2006 showed one low detection, far below the federal limit, that the plume did not appear to have reached the McCullom Lake area, and that monitoring should continue. In a June 2009 letter, the Illinois EPA said the plume had not affected any private, semi-private or public water supply wells and that a dozen nearby private wells sampled in late 2008 showed no contaminants of concern. The county's May 2010 sampling found no volatile organic compounds at any of 15 locations in the village.

The case ended in a settlement. The Chicago Tribune reported that 33 plaintiffs settled with Rohm and Haas, a Dow subsidiary, in December 2014 after a suit that was dismissed in 2010 and reinstated on appeal, with terms not disclosed.

What I take from it as an agent: this is history, and the testing record after 2006 is what a buyer can check. It is also one more reason to order a full well test, including volatile organic compounds, on any private well here. The county health department is the place to ask about current results.

Schools

McCullom Lake Schools: McHenry District 15 and District 156

The village's "How do I" page says students living in McCullom Lake are served by schools in District 15 and District 156, both based in the City of McHenry. That is a simpler picture than Wonder Lake, where three districts meet around one lake.

For pre-kindergarten through eighth grade, McHenry School District 15 says it serves about 4,100 students across five elementary schools and two middle schools: Edgebrook and Hilltop (kindergarten to third grade), Duker (fourth and fifth), Riverwood and Valley View (kindergarten to fifth), and McHenry and Parkland middle schools. Which elementary a village address feeds is set by the district's attendance map, so use the District 15 boundary map or call the district.

High school is McHenry Community High School in District 156. According to the village's August 2026 newsletter, high school started August 12 and pre-K through eighth grade on August 19 this year.

Assignment is by address. Homes just outside the village, toward Ringwood Road and beyond, can fall in different districts, so confirm each house with the district before you write an offer, and ask me if you want it checked for a specific address.

Illustration of a large brick community high school with a flagpole, representing McHenry Community High School in McCullom Lake, Illinois
AI illustration, not a photo of McHenry Community High School.

McHenry School District 15. Pre-K through grade 8: Edgebrook and Hilltop (K-3), Duker (4-5), Riverwood and Valley View (K-5), McHenry Middle and Parkland Middle (6-8). Check the boundary map.

McHenry Community High School. District 156.

Commute & Access

Commuting from McCullom Lake: McHenry or Crystal Lake Metra

McCullom Lake is closer to a Metra station than most lake villages. The McHenry station on the Union Pacific Northwest line is about 1.8 miles from the village hall in a straight line. The catch is how little service it has.

According to Metra's schedule data for fall 2026, three trains leave McHenry for Ogilvie Transportation Center on weekdays, at 5:24, 6:24 and 7:24 a.m., and each takes 82 minutes. Three come back, leaving Ogilvie at 3:22, 4:22 and 5:22 p.m., in 88 minutes. There is no midday, evening or weekend service at McHenry. If your hours fit that window, it works. If they do not, you drive farther.

Crystal Lake is the flexible option, about 8.5 miles away in a straight line. The same schedule data shows 27 weekday trains to Ogilvie and 25 back, with the fastest trips at 67 minutes. On weekends Crystal Lake has 15 inbound trains on Saturday and 9 on Sunday.

The honest math: for a five-day downtown commute with any schedule flexibility, plan on driving to Crystal Lake most days. For a hybrid schedule that lines up with the three McHenry trains, McCullom Lake is one of the easier lake villages to commute from.

Illustration of a commuter train at a small-town station platform in morning light, representing the McHenry commuter rail station in McCullom Lake, Illinois
AI illustration, not a photo of the McHenry commuter rail station.
Commute & Access

Driving from McCullom Lake: Route 31, Route 120 and the Village Roads

The village sits between Ringwood Road on the west and Route 31 to the east, with McCullom Lake Road along its north edge. Route 31 runs south into McHenry and Crystal Lake and north toward Richmond, and Route 120 through McHenry heads east toward Lake County and west to Woodstock. There is no interstate nearby.

Inside the village, the roads are narrow and the rules are strict. The resident guide caps trucks at 6 tons except local delivery, bans semi trucks and trailers, and bans riding mowers, dirt bikes, four-wheelers and scooters on village roads. Any vehicle parked on the street needs a free permit requested 24 hours ahead, parked vehicles must be 18 inches off the road, there is no parking within 20 feet of an intersection, and nobody parks on the street after two inches of snow. The board adopted a new parking ordinance, Ordinance 579, on July 21, 2026.

The village has been rebuilding its streets in pieces. The September 23, 2025 minutes describe new curb, gutter and drainage and repaving on Orchard, Forest View and Spring, and a $2 million IDOT grant application to resurface every street, which the village did not receive, according to the October 2025 minutes. In 2026 the village teamed with the McHenry Township Road District on Spring Road, and the July 21, 2026 minutes report the first course of asphalt down with curbs and gutters in. Ask which streets are done when you tour.

Commute & Access

Getting Around McCullom Lake: Walking, Golf Carts and the Water

McCullom Lake is walkable in the small-village sense and car-dependent in every other sense. Walk Score's McCullom Lake page counts about one restaurant, bar or coffee shop in the village and says residents can walk to an average of 0.2 of them in five minutes. The village hall on Orchard Drive scores 15 out of 100, car-dependent.

What you can walk to is the lake. From almost anywhere in the village, the park, the beach and the launch are a few blocks away, and that is what buyers here are paying for. Groceries, pharmacies and everything else mean a drive into McHenry.

Golf carts are part of the culture. The McCullom Lake Kart Club runs an annual golf cart poker run for charity; in 2026 it started at the village hall on May 30 and, according to the village's July 2026 newsletter, raised $6,000 for the McHenry High School District 156 Foundation plus food donations. Before you buy one, ask the village office what the current rules are for carts on village streets.

Shopping & Dining

Eating Out and Errands in McCullom Lake

McCullom Lake has one real place to eat out, and it doubles as the village's meeting room. The village's community guide lists Cullom Knoll at 3018 Hickory Drive, a bar and grill known for its Friday fish fry with all-you-can-eat cod and beer-battered bluegill or walleye, with two renovated party spaces. The Neighbors Helping Neighbors group holds its monthly meetings in the Knoll's back room, according to the September 2026 village newsletter.

The same directory lists a few other local businesses, including a custom cheesecake caterer who lives in the village, a tree service and a self-storage facility. The village's own pitch is to shop local when you can.

For everything else, plan on the City of McHenry. There is no grocery store, pharmacy or gas station in the village, so weekly errands are a short drive south or east.

Illustration of a small corner bar and grill on a lakeside residential street at evening, representing Cullom Knoll on Hickory Drive in McCullom Lake in McCullom Lake, Illinois
AI illustration, not a photo of Cullom Knoll on Hickory Drive in McCullom Lake.
Parks & Recreation

Parks, the Beach and Open Space Near McCullom Lake

The village runs a handful of small parks. The main one is the village park and beach on the lake, which got new swings and three fire pits in July 2026, according to the July 21, 2026 minutes. Zender Park got a new sign in 2026, and the board minutes also refer to a park up by Forest Glen, which the minutes call Jello Park, where the benches are being replaced. The village beach is also where the fall car show and bonfire happen.

Next door, the City of McHenry's Petersen Park at 4300 Petersen Park Road covers the northeast shore, with a swimming beach, boat rentals and rentable shelters, according to the city's parks page. IDNR notes a handicap-accessible fishing pier there, open spring through fall. It is about two-thirds of a mile from the village hall in a straight line.

The big open space is about 4 miles north. Glacial Park in Ringwood is the McHenry County Conservation District's most popular site: more than 3,400 acres, eight miles of trails, a five-mile stretch of the 26-mile Prairie Trail along its eastern edge, fishing on Nippersink Creek, the Lost Valley Visitor Center, and cross-country ski and nine miles of snowmobile trails in winter.

On the lake itself, the winter tradition is ice fishing when the ice cooperates. The village's annual fishing derby was scheduled for January 24, 2026, and cancelled because of open water.

Illustration of a creek through tallgrass prairie with a trail in fall, representing Nippersink Creek at Glacial Park in McCullom Lake, Illinois
AI illustration, not a photo of Nippersink Creek at Glacial Park.
Community Life

Potlucks, the Car Show and McCullom Lake's Yearly Rhythm

McCullom Lake's calendar is small-town and mostly on the beach. The village newsletters list a potluck dinner at the village hall on the third Thursday of every month at 6 p.m., and the Neighbors Helping Neighbors group meets monthly at Cullom Knoll.

The fall is the busy season. The police department's car show on the beach ran September 20, 2025 and raised $750, according to the September 23, 2025 minutes, and the 2026 edition on September 19 added a craft fair. Neighbors Helping Neighbors has a bonfire on the beach planned for October 10, 2026, with a possible chili cook-off, and bingo at the village hall on November 14, 2026, according to the September 2026 newsletter.

Spring and summer bring the Kart Club's golf cart poker run in late May and the beach opening once the state license arrives. Fireworks are prohibited in the village, and the police department reminds residents of that every July. The fishing derby runs in January when the ice allows it.

If you want to understand the place before you buy, go to a potluck and a board meeting in the same month. The board meets on the fourth Tuesday at 7 p.m. at the village hall, and the minutes are posted online.

Illustration of classic cars lined up beside a small lake beach, representing the car show on the village beach in McCullom Lake in McCullom Lake, Illinois
AI illustration, not a photo of the car show on the village beach in McCullom Lake.
Practical Logistics

Police, Fire, Trash, Stickers and Other Services in McCullom Lake

McCullom Lake has more village rules per square foot than most places I work, and a buyer should know them before moving in. The village police department patrols the village, and non-emergency calls also go through McHenry County dispatch. Fire and ambulance come from the McHenry Township Fire Protection District, which the village's "How do I" page says responds 24 hours a day from four stations. Your fire district is a line on the tax bill.

Every vehicle housed in the village needs a village sticker within 30 days of moving in, and by March 31 each year, according to the resident guide. A car sticker is $20, a B-plate truck $25 and a motorcycle $8, with a reduced $15 rate for some owners and a $10 late charge starting April 1. A vehicle needs a sticker if it is in the village 14 of any 20 days, wherever it is registered.

Trash goes through the village's contract hauler, LRS, which picks up trash and recycling on Monday mornings with unlimited trash and recycling. One small bulk item under 4 feet and 50 pounds a week goes out free; large items and appliances cost $35 with a day's notice. Yard waste season runs April 1 to November 30, a 95-gallon yard waste cart rents for $3 a month, and LRS vacuums leaves once in spring and twice in fall.

Other rules worth knowing: a permit for any change to a structure, a permit for garage sales (two a year, no more than four days each), pool barrier requirements, a limit of four dogs per home, lawns under 8 inches, and the McHenry County burning ordinance, which bans burning leaves and yard waste. The village's page points residents to the McHenry Public Library; whether your parcel pays that library district's levy is on the tax bill.

Community Resources

Hospitals Near McCullom Lake

The closest full-service hospital is Northwestern Medicine McHenry Hospital at 4201 West Medical Center Drive in McHenry, about 3.4 miles south of the village hall in a straight line. Emergency calls go through the McHenry Township Fire Protection District's ambulances.

What's Changing

What's Being Built in McCullom Lake: Forest Glen and the Edges

A village this built-out has one real development site, and it is being decided now. Forest Glen is a platted but unbuilt subdivision on the west side of the village off Ringwood Road. At the August 5, 2026 zoning hearing, the village attorney said a plan had been approved there since 2005 under R-2 zoning, so anyone with financing could apply to build single-family homes of 2,500 to 3,500 square feet, but that it had sat vacant because that project was no longer feasible. The April 28, 2026 minutes put it at 50 lots in two phases.

The current proposal is a senior care community. Developer Ben Valletta has proposed six 16-resident assisted living and memory care lodges and ten independent living cottages for residents 55 and older, about 120 residents in total, run by one operating company, with private roads, an entrance only from Ringwood Road, emergency-only access to Orchard Drive, and City of McHenry water brought to the site. He estimated construction at about three years. The zoning board voted unanimously on August 5, 2026 to recommend a special use permit for a planned unit development, with a variation allowing it on 12 acres instead of the required 20. As of the September 22, 2026 village board agenda, final approval was still pending before the village board.

Two smaller items are worth knowing. At the September 23, 2025 meeting, a landowner near Flanders and Ringwood roads, outside the village, floated storage units and about 64 to 66 one-bedroom ranch apartments, and the village estimated a 2,000-foot sewer extension at $800,000 to $1 million. In November 2025 a solar developer proposed a 10 to 40 acre community solar project nearby, and trustees said they were not for it at that time.

For buyers, the Forest Glen outcome matters mostly to the streets around it. The current plan keeps its traffic on Ringwood Road instead of Orchard Drive. If the senior plan fails, the old R-2 single-family approval is still there.

I don't label any town or neighborhood as safe or unsafe.

Before You Buy

Flood Risk, Drainage and High Groundwater in McCullom Lake

Redfin, using First Street's model, rates McCullom Lake's overall flood risk as minimal over the next 30 years. That matches the ground: much of the village slopes up from the lake toward McCullom Lake Road, and the flat, poorly drained land the 1992 study describes is mostly along the east and south shores, outside the village.

The more common problem here is water that is not a flood. The 1992 study found the water table near the lake and its small tributaries is often within five feet of the surface. The village code backs that up: its zoning requires most of a new lot's minimum area to sit at least three feet above the high water line and above the highest groundwater level. Drainage is an ongoing board topic; the April 28, 2026 minutes mention flooding on Parkview near the horse farm and a planned catch basin and ditching.

Two checks before you write an offer. Look the address up on the FEMA flood map, because a mapped flood zone can mean required flood insurance on a mortgage. And ask the seller directly what the basement or crawl space did in the last heavy rain, and whether there is a sump pump and when it last ran.

Quick Answers

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does a house cost in McCullom Lake, IL?+

Zillow's home value index was $236,382 for August 2026, up 5.2% in a year. Redfin reported a median sale price of $175,000 for the three months ending August 2026, but that rests on a handful of sales; eight closings from April to early September 2026 ranged from $55,000 to $325,000.

Who owns McCullom Lake?+

Mostly the City of McHenry. The 1992 Clean Lakes study lists the lake bottom as 86.1% owned by the City of McHenry, 4.5% by the Village of McCullom Lake and 9.4% by others. The city took over most of the lake in 1984, and IDNR manages the fishery with the city.

Can you swim and boat on McCullom Lake?+

Yes, within limits. Village residents use the village beach, open 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. in season, and a gated launch with a $5 annual key. Boats are limited to 14 feet and 10 horsepower, or 25 horsepower for pontoons, and jet skis are not allowed. The beach occasionally closes for high bacteria, as it did for one day in August 2026.

Do I have to connect to the sewer when I buy a house in McCullom Lake?+

Yes. Under village code Section 14-27, a buyer must connect to the village sewer within 90 days of closing and should complete the sewer application and pay the $250 fee before closing. Failing to get the village's connection letter can cost $100 a day. Ask early whether the house is already connected.

Do McCullom Lake homes have city water?+

No. Homes in the village are on private wells. The planned Forest Glen senior community would bring in City of McHenry water for that site only, and the village president said in August 2026 that it will not be available to village residents. Test the well on every purchase.

What are property taxes in McCullom Lake, IL?+

The median effective rate is about 2.43%, with a median bill of about $3,967 (Ownwell, April 2026). Bills usually rise after a sale once the home is reassessed, and the village's own share of the bill is about 4%.

What school district is McCullom Lake, IL in?+

The village says students are served by McHenry School District 15 for pre-K through eighth grade and District 156 for high school, which is McHenry Community High School. The District 15 boundary map sets which elementary a house feeds, so confirm each address with the district.

Does McCullom Lake have a Metra station?+

No, but McHenry's station is about 1.8 miles away. It has three inbound weekday trains, at 5:24, 6:24 and 7:24 a.m., each taking 82 minutes to Ogilvie, and no weekend service. Crystal Lake, about 8.5 miles away, has 27 inbound weekday trains.

Eshu Chikoti has extensive access to off-market listings throughout McCullom Lake and the rest of McHenry County — homes that never make it to the public listing sites. That matters right now: in a seller's market like this one, well-priced homes routinely go under contract within days, and buyers relying only on public listings are competing for whatever is left over. Working with someone plugged into off-market inventory means seeing homes before the crowd does.

Eshu Chikoti · 847-691-4282 ·

Get new McCullom Lake listings by email

When a home comes on the market in McCullom Lake, I'll email it to you.

Just your email. Unsubscribe any time by replying.

Thinking About McCullom Lake?

Whether you're buying, selling, or just curious what's on the market, I can walk you through McCullom Lake street by street.